Skip to main content

"The Book is Always Better Than the Movie"

Image result for the help book cover design
Anybody else agree with the title? I know I do. It's sort of like a "duh" statement.

I am a big believer, also, in reading the book before watching the movie. So when I learned that my eighth grade English class was going to watch The Help, I may or may not have found an online version and started reading it in class instead of watching the movie.

Image result for paper towns movieA lot of book to movie adaptations are pretty good. I remember crying at The Fault in Our Stars movie as much as I did during the book. Paper Towns was also pretty good and funny. The Hunger Games movies were decent and I loved  The Book Thief and If I Stay. Leonardo DiCaprio, among other elements in The Great Gatsby movie, as Jay Gatsby made The Great Gatsby as enjoyable as the book. The Outsiders was a decent adaptation and Divergent (the first one) plus a good handful of the Harry Potter movies are as good as their books too (but not better than).

Image result for the book thief book coverIt's really the bad book to movie adaptations I remember. You know the ones. The ones where you'll gasp and gape at the screen when something completely wrong happens in the movie, something that never happened in the book or something that came out of nowhere and was added in there to appease the audience rather than tell the right story (Allegiant, anybody?).

Also, the sixth Harry Potter movie. Ugh. That was my favorite Harry Potter book, but the most disappointing Harry Potter movie. I think all the Potterheads out there know what I'm talking about. There's at least one movie that doesn't do it for them, and I have to say The Half-Blood Prince didn't live up to the greatness of the book.
Image result for the great gatsby movie
Here's another movie that will forever be considered awful in the eyes of the fandom: The Mortal Instruments movie. First of all, what even happened there? I read the book and I knew everything that was going on, but then I watched the movie and it got more confusing as it went on. That's not supposed to happen! The movies are supposed to be simple enough for the crazy people who don't read the book to understand!

Image result for city of bones book coverLastly, and most disappointingly, the Percy Jackson movie saga. The books are wonderful, and always will be. It's those movies, though. It's not even that Annabeth's hair isn't blonde in the first one (or that when they badly dyed the actress's hair blonde in the second one) that annoyed the fans: it's how the second movie went down that sent fans in a downward spiral of doom. The second movie didn't even follow the second book, and it tried to combine the last three books into it so the people behind the movie wouldn't have to spend more money making three other movies. How awful is that? If you haven't seen the Percy Jackson movies but have read the book, don't waste your time on these movies. Trust me.

Image result for percy jackson movie annabethI think where all these movies went wrong (Allegiant, Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, The Mortal Instruments City of Bones and the Percy Jackson movies) is that the screenwriters didn't follow the books as closely as they should have. Now, don't get me wrong, the tiny differences between the books and the movies are what make each of them so great and wonderful to compare, but I don't think screenwriters should stray far from the book, considering they have the book to thank for their screenwriting job.

Image result for allegiant book coverI believe that if screenwriter's are going to change anything, at least leave the beginnings and the ends alone. For sure, Allegiant--in my opinion--was adapted pretty well until near the end, where the screenwriter completely changed the ending. I was mad, because the book ended the way the book was ended and that was that. By changing the end of movie, the screenwriter, in essence, changed the whole meaning and message of the story and ruined for movie-goers who don't read the books the original story.

Image result for book to movie adaptationsI'll address the last two points briefly. My expectations for books versus their movies are different: usually, I expect that the book be better than the movie. I have yet to fall upon an adaptation that is better than the book. Wouldn't it be funny and weirdly coincidental if my adaptation book (The Lovely Bones) has a better movie? Lastly, I don't believe that there are adaptations that have been made into unnecessary films. Every story that has been published has been published for a reason. The story is now shared with the world, and if the people in Hollywood decide to help in the sharing of that story, then that is wonderful. Even if the adaptation is bad, that doesn't mean the movie was unnecessary. Getting the story out there (even if it's the wrong story or a poorly adapted version of the story) is all that matters. Isn't that why people write books in the first place?

*None of the book covers, movie stills or artwork is mine. All rights go to the wonderful artists.*
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Lovely Bones Book vs. Movie Review

The Lovely Bones book cover I am a firm believer that the book is always better than the movie/tv series. I could point you to multiple examples where the characters were botched on screen, or plot holes prevailed. The statement that the book is better than the movie usually holds true However, with the increased use of streaming services and the increased utilization of published book material being pulled into the movie/tv world, more and more of our familiar stories are being put to the screen, and hence being put to the test. Some pass: despite some alterations and plot changes, the story and characters remain relatively the same, which bolsters excitement from the fan base. However, others don't, and screenplays that drastically alter the storyline leave fans wishing for a do-over. I definitely have some conflicted feelings regarding The Lovely Bones  and its book-to-movie adaptation. I really did like the book. It's not my favorite, or by any means the best book...
2 comments
Read more

The Dark Artifices Series Review

I have been reading Cassandra Clare's work since I was a freshman, and have avidly followed the release dates of her Dark Artifices series. I felt like even just these past four years I could track all the amazing improvements she's made in her storytelling, world-building, and characterization. Being a writer myself, I know that there is so much that goes behind make choices for the novel or choosing the best paths for the characters. These decisions that can be extremely hard for the author, especially if you're an author as Cassandra Clare, and even more so when those decisions are made for the third book in a trilogy whose ending has been much anticipated.  Overall, I give Cassandra Clare's The Dark Artifices  series 5/5 stars. I loved the pacing of the stories and how intimate the storytelling is, even if I wasn't quite satisfied with the ending of The Queen of Air and Darkness , which is what I'll be talking about below. I enjoyed all of the plo...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Bronze Key Book Review

To be destroyed from within is more dangerous than having an outside enemy. It's easy to turn against the people you thought you knew and trusted when a mysterious spy enters the story. With this new enemy, the kids of the Magisterium face a new threat, one they can't see. The third book in the Magisterium series is cleverly crafted; the authors point readers to where they want us to look, so no one can guess what's coming. Striking and heartbreaking, with such a crazy cliffhanger, Holly Black and Cassandra Clare succeed again at writing another well-paced, action-packed, complex middle grade novel.  Holly Black and Cassandra Clare first met over ten years ago at Holly's first-ever book signing. They have since become good friends, bonding over (among other things) their shared love of fantasy. With Magisterium, they decided to team up to write their own story about heroes and villains, good and evil, and being chosen for greatness, whether you like it or not. Holly is...
Post a Comment
Read more